DAO Treasury Management RFP
Cast your vote
Options
Multi-choice (approval) voting — votes shown per option, ranked by support.
- ★Avantgarde1.58M SCR
- kpk227.1K SCR
- 9Summits108.75 SCR
- 0xaeb0...ec96 Abstain500K SCR
Auto-abstaining wallet is abstaining
- 0xdonpepe.eth Avantgarde410.1K SCR
https://forum.scroll.io/t/0xdonpepe-delegate-thread/1041/2?u=0xdonpepe
- delegate.l2beat.eth Avantgarde400.74K SCR
- olimpio.eth Avantgarde179.16K SCR
- the-monsters.eth kpk99.19K SCR
- eventhorizoncommunity.eth Avantgarde87.33K SCR
- compound-dao.eth Avantgarde70.04K SCR
- 0xea17...6676 Abstain55.26K SCR
- scroll.seedgov.eth Avantgarde52.2K SCR
- cypherlab.eth kpk45.27K SCR
- pgov.eth Avantgarde40.51K SCR
- bitblondy-gov.eth Avantgarde39.15K SCR
- surybonfil.eth Avantgarde38.24K SCR
I’m voting in favor given the stronger fee structure, risk management approach, and added value through partnerships and experience.
- 34.89K SCR
We vote for KPK to manage the DAO's treasury, recognizing that its conservative, stable, and profitable approach is ideal for a new DAO, which is taking its first steps in controlling its treasury. KPK's strategy provides a secure foundation, thanks to its experience and knowledge in the field, and prioritizes stability and capital preservation, ensuring that the DAO's treasury is managed with security and reliability as fundamental elements.
- jensei.eth Avantgarde29.88K SCR
Treasury management is critical for Scroll DAO’s sustainability. After review, I support Avantgarde. Their approach goes beyond capital preservation, aligning treasury strategy with DAO priorities like sustainability, stable funding, and ecosystem growth. They’ve also shown strong engagement with delegates and openness to DAO oversight, which reinforces accountability. I am looking forward to track the progress going forward.
- 0x76e4...a876 Avantgarde29.25K SCR
- 0x906f...0b0c Avantgarde25.6K SCR
- seiryuu.eth Avantgarde24.66K SCR
I vote FOR Avantgarde. Their proposal appears stronger, and feedback from other delegates reinforced my confidence in their approach
- connorm.eth Avantgarde23.76K SCR
https://play.negationgame.com/s/scroll/rationale/pXf-g8YAFpuigkWkqLjcf
- socket.eth kpk21.66K SCR
- 0xb62e...e495 Avantgarde21.25K SCR
I am voting for Avantgarde because I like their offer more, it's flexible, they want to collaborate with other service providers and have been very open for feedback from delegates.
- sovereignsignal.eth Abstain18.38K SCR
I have my rationale on abstaining here: https://forum.scroll.io/t/sov-delegate-thread/94/4?u=sov
- aretagov.eth Abstain17.86K SCR
- curia-delegates.eth Avantgarde16.57K SCR
https://forum.scroll.io/t/curia-delegate-thread/616/6
- mexi.wtf kpk12.81K SCR
I would like to see their Gradual Stablecoin Diversification via CEXs implemented and tested.
- launamu.eth Avantgarde12.75K SCR
- cypherbadger.eth kpk10.8K SCR
- 0x901d...fe7d Avantgarde10.46K SCR
Please see my delegate profile for my rationale.
- gov.fireeyesdao.eth Abstain10.09K SCR
- modularcryptoxyz.eth Avantgarde9.6K SCR
- antoinevergne.eth Avantgarde8.48K SCR
What I really like with Avantgarde is their approach of having a real discussion with the DAO about the exact strategy. On top of that, their cost structure looks more affordable than the other options, which is important for us as we start professionalizing treasury management. I also see a big plus in the fact that they could help deploy MYSO on Scroll. That would be a win for the ecosystem, adding another layer of utility and growth. And finally, Avantgarde’s long experience working with strong teams across the space gives me confidence they can bring real value to Scroll.
- 0x8b58...69b7 Avantgarde7.86K SCR
After havign reviewed all proposals, I believe Avantgarde provides competitive pricing with also robust expertise
- benedictvs.eth Avantgarde7.74K SCR
- leyzerok.eth Avantgarde6.92K SCR
- kevinknielsen.eth Avantgarde6.85K SCR
You can find our full rationale in our delegate thread: https://forum.scroll.io/t/proxy-prev-boardroom-delegate-thread/561/8
- aranadigital.eth Avantgarde5.52K SCR
- 0xc0c3...475d Abstain5.51K SCR
- axianetwork.eth Abstain4.33K SCR
- tanegov.eth Avantgarde3.56K SCR
- 0xc554...7759 Avantgarde3.52K SCR
We support for Avantgarde. Their proactive engagement with delegates and holistic strategy to use treasury assets to directly foster growth within the Scroll ecosystem is most compelling.
- alexsotodigital.eth Abstain3.01K SCR
While there is extensive documentation and in-depth comparisons between the different providers, I don't feel I have enough insight to choose one in particular. I trust that other delegates with more background will guide us in the right direction.
- ignasdefi.eth Avantgarde2.8K SCR
- juanrah.eth Avantgarde2.6K SCR
- 0x617d...f695 kpk1.02K SCR
I believe KPK’s diverse team and proven governance background make them the best option to ensure transparent, decentralized, and sustainable treasury management for Scroll DAO.
- 0x807b...34fc kpk972.34 SCR
- lexx77.eth Avantgarde606.28 SCR
- 0xe73a...d125 Avantgarde540 SCR
I choose Avantgarde due to the following reasons: 1. After checking the Negation Game, I found out that the fee is 5% cheaper, which is a significant number 2. They contacted me directly, which talks about their extra-mile effort for reaching results, I expect that if they reached a low rank delegate to solve any questions or clarify info they will do the most detailed thing to deliver the results they commit to. 3. Made an AI in-depth assessment of the three providers and the result was: the Avantgarde proposal is recommended as the best-balanced choice. It would provide Scroll DAO with a professional, one-stop treasury management solution that achieves sustainable yield (via options and DeFi yields) forum.scroll.io forum.scroll.io , maintains decentralized custody and oversight forum.scroll.io forum.scroll.io , and institutes comprehensive risk controls appropriate for a DAO treasury forum.scroll.io forum.scroll.io . Furthermore, Avantgarde’s emphasis on growing the Scroll ecosystem – by deploying new on-chain financial infrastructure – aligns with the DAO’s long-term interests beyond just financial returns forum.scroll.io forum.scroll.io . Their plan is ambitious but grounded in expertise and past experience with similar treasuries, increasing confidence in execution. By selecting Avantgarde, Scroll DAO would be entrusting its treasury to a team that not only safeguards and grows the assets, but also acts as a strategic partner in building out Scroll’s decentralized future…
- defimova.eth Abstain176.92 SCR
- 0x0057b…915c8 Avantgarde137.47 SCR
- 0x01695…0eb01 Avantgarde120 SCR
- 0x09b17…9cb4b Avantgarde110.86 SCR
- 0xcbd5e…a8edc kpk104.99 SCR
- tweenky.eth Avantgarde100.68 SCR
- 0x4c29d…91a57 Avantgarde100 SCR
- 0xac236…28f59 9Summits98.03 SCR
- 0x2bea...1065 kpk92.54 SCR
- 0x2d5b2…ea430 kpk91 SCR
- 0x93e5d…d045e kpk88.73 SCR
- 0x413a9…e1af3 Avantgarde87.78 SCR
- 0xf5f15…06413 Avantgarde80.02 SCR
- 0x0c338…e6b25 Avantgarde80 SCR
- 0x9fc40…cf78b kpk80 SCR
- 0x7cecb…70dc1 Avantgarde77.47 SCR
- 0x1e39c…882d4 Avantgarde70.44 SCR
- 0x1fc8b…a933d Avantgarde68.36 SCR
- 0x2be21…f4873 Avantgarde66.77 SCR
- 0x6cd4...8fcd Avantgarde65.86 SCR
- 0x09a6...6bd9 Avantgarde47.94 SCR
- 0x7ea74…5b267 kpk45.15 SCR
- 0x1a925…82d56 Avantgarde44.87 SCR
- 0x73bca…3de09 Abstain42.86 SCR
- 0x45e92…b448a Avantgarde42.58 SCR
- 0x22bf...9208 Abstain41.62 SCR
- 0xebdd8…668a9 Abstain41.09 SCR
- 0xb62ff…92b83 Abstain40.86 SCR
- 0x11a1a…43771 Abstain39.87 SCR
- 0x72cac…986fd Abstain39.19 SCR
- 0x926e7…080a2 Abstain39.17 SCR
- 0x6de1...2309 Avantgarde31.7 SCR
- 0x44ec...4859 Avantgarde22.03 SCR
- 0xfe1c6…8da0c Avantgarde17.1 SCR
- 0xca84...b66f Abstain15.05 SCR
- 0x3aec...52a8 Avantgarde11.89 SCR
- 0xee49f…03a44 9Summits10.72 SCR
- 0x3a88...8da0 Avantgarde10 SCR
- lamprosdao.eth Avantgarde9.36 SCR
https://forum.scroll.io/t/lampros-dao-delegate-thread/1091/2?u=euphoria
- 0x2bcd...b5c3 Avantgarde8.62 SCR
- 0x69ed...c5c0 kpk4 SCR
- topobadger.eth Avantgarde2.5 SCR
- 0x9baa...cb58 kpk2.5 SCR
- 0x757f...beb6 Avantgarde2 SCR
- 0x94b0...077f Avantgarde2 SCR
- 0x05912…37128 Avantgarde0.95 SCR
- 0x2d0af…d4350 Avantgarde0 SCR
- 0x82e7b…cbeaa 9Summits0 SCR
- 0xcb156…aa1a0 Abstain0 SCR
- 0x9b27...16ac Avantgarde0 SCR
DAO Treasury Management RFP
Overview
Earlier in August, a [proposal was posted](https://forum.scroll.io/t/request-for-proposals-dao-treasury-management/1047 on the Scroll governance forum outlining a request for proposals for treasury management.
Three responses came in:
There was more information shared in 1-1 calls with Avant Garde and kpk, which can be found here.
This proposal is about choosing a service provider based on the information provided to date. Additional negotiations can take place with the provider that is voted on.
Request for Proposal
The governance team invites qualified service providers to submit proposals to support the DAO in developing a robust treasury management strategy for the DAO treasury. We are particularly interested in teams with demonstrated experience managing on-chain assets, supporting DAO governance processes, and designing transparent, risk-aware financial systems.
This is an opportunity to help shape Scroll’s financial future - not just by managing assets, but by co-designing the frameworks and tools that will support long-term sustainability, decentralization, and protocol alignment.
We welcome proposals from:
- Treasury management companies/DAOs
- On-chain risk and financial modeling teams
- DAO-native strategists and financial consultants
- Service providers with experience in tooling
All proposals will be reviewed by the Foundation and the DAO. Qualified teams may present their proposal publicly on governance calls and/or take part in a pilot program or deeper scoping round.
All submitted proposals will be evaluated based on the following criteria:
- Strategic fit: alignment with Scroll DAO’s mission & values.
- Relevant experience
- Treasury & risk management approach
- Tooling
- Cost
- Willingness to potentially work alongside other service providers
- Commitment to consistent public reporting (with an outline of the frequency / nature of updates)
Submission Guidelines
Who can apply: Treasury management companies/DAOs, on-chain risk and financial modeling teams, DAO-native strategists and financial consultants as well as service providers with experience in tooling.
What to include:
- Overview of your team and relevant DAO experience
- Description of proposed services
- Tooling or protocol integrations
- Pricing
- Risk frameworks and assumptions
- Reporting cadence (examples from other work is helpful)
- Disclosure of conflicts of interest (including any existing relationships with or investments from Scroll DAO delegates)
- Case studies (examples from your work in other DAOs)>
Proposal Deadline: Mon August 18th, 2025 at midnight UTC-8.
Community Feedback
The DAO community brought up the following points as well:
- Bear market preparedness
- Having a stable coin balance to pay for grants or service providers / to minimize downward sell pressure
- Integration plans with DVT or similar technologies
- Slashing insurance
- Transparent operator composition (ideally including DAO-aligned node runners)
9Summits
Overview of our Team and Relevant DAO Experience
9summits is a curation company specializing in on-chain risk management and market-neutral strategies. Founded by Rémi, the company is currently curating over $85 million in various market-neutral strategies. One of the existing clients is Ethereum France which showcases strong performance, successful multi-year track record and auditable experience in DAO treasury management.
Description of Proposed Services
For Scroll DAO, 9summits proposes to design and implement a long-term treasury management strategy that begins with a comprehensive audit of current assets and a clear understanding on the DAO’s missions. This will be followed by the creation of an allocation plan that matches Scroll DAO’s targets. The approach will secure the DAO’s capacity to fund grants, operations, and ecosystem programs while minimizing the risk of downward sell pressure during market downturns. Throughout the engagement, we will provide continuous monitoring of the treasury’s health using on-chain analytics and real-time alerts, while ensuring that all major treasury decisions are presented and discussed with the community before execution.
The rest of their response is here.
Avantgarde
Proposed Services: Holistic Treasury Management
In the months leading up to the RFP, we’ve had numerous conversations with delegates in the Scroll DAO to better understand how delegates would like to see the treasury being managed and utilized. This proposal is built on the feedback we got, and is our invitation to a strategic partnership to bring holistic management to the DAO’s treasury.
The outlined approach addresses the DAO’s key objectives—extending the runway, mitigating risk, and ensuring a stable financial foundation for funding programs and contributors for years to come—but also aims to foster activity and growth within the Scroll DeFi ecosystem through strategic asset allocation and protocol deployments, to align treasury actions with the DAO’s broader strategic goals. The proposed partnership will be founded on transparent operational processes and accounting to provide not only a clear overview and point of contact for the DAO’s finances, but also the necessary financial context to make strategic decisions and structuring actionable financial plans for the DAO, whether it’s grants programs or other growth initiatives.
We would look to work closely with the DAO (or possibly the newly proposed Execution Oversight Council) to ensure that the deployed strategies accurately reflects the DAO’s current risk tolerance and overall objectives, and with the DAO’s input outline a treasury management policy framework to guide the mandate (such as the % of funds earmarked for the different strategic parts). Lastly, we are not opposed to collaborating with other service providers, if that is what the DAO prefers.
The rest of the proposal can be found here.
kpk
Summary This proposal outlines a collaboration between kpk and Scroll, focused on managing Scroll’s Treasury.
If approved, kpk will non-custodially manage ~20M SCR before Oct-2025 and ~20M additional SCR once they are unlocked in October. The treasury will gradually diversify by accumulating stablecoins through strategies defined by kpk’s research team, within our strict risk-management framework. This will allow Scroll to extend its runway and cover its expenses without selling SCR, increasing the capability of the treasury to fund future initiatives and retribute its contributors with stablecoins.
Scroll DAO retains the right to terminate this agreement through its governance mechanism.
The rest of the proposal can be found here.
Voting over time
97 votes over the voting period
Proposal ID 1773671628… · data from on-chain Governor + SCR token (Scroll mainnet RPC) — durable source of truth